I'm a little surprised to find today that suggested edits I approve don't automatically go through. I used the suggested edits queue to approve an edit to this post, only to find that it still doesn't show and the post as the edit(1) thing showing a pending edit. Opening this shows a modal action box with this message:

You have already reviewed this item. It needs more reviews from other users to be completed.

As a 20k+ user, I can edit posts and have them go through immediately. I used to be able to approve suggested edits as well.

Is this feature broken or did something change?

share

1 Answer 1

up vote 8 down vote accepted

As with most odd cases on Stack Exchange, this is SO's fault. SO has always required two people to approve edits; everywhere else required one. They continued to have problems with terrible edits getting accepted, so in October SO's requirements were increased so three votes are needed, and at the same time all the other sites on the network, including us, were bumped up to two votes

The theory is that making your own edit is easier than reviewing somebody else's. People seem to have a habit of glancing at an edit and thinking "that seems not horrifying", and clicking Approve, when that edit wasn't actually very good and they never would've made it themselves. Requiring multiple reviewers hopefully avoids that, although I don't really think we had that problem here to begin with

share
8  
Grrr-a-humbug. I'm going to suggest that even if 2 votes are required now, 10k+ users reviews should be trusted a little more on 2.0 sites like ours where reviews take longer to come in. –  Caleb Dec 6 '12 at 8:53

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .