The distinction between the tags and isn't very clear. The tag wiki excerpt for reads

This tag covers both bootloader issues (what happens before the operating system starts) and the starting up of the operating system.

However, I think since this excerpt was written almost two years ago we've mostly been using for bootloader issues (up to loading the kernel) and for the OS startup (init, rc scripts and so on). I think we should make this distinction official, and retag the few questions that will then be mistagged. Any opposition?

Also, on which side of the fence do initrd issues fall?

Do we really need two separate tags for this? The [/boot] tag wiki covers both (include initrd/initramfs/init). They're both pretty broad/ambiguous and need (IMO) at least one other tag to be useful. –  Mat Jan 2 '13 at 18:05
As you can see I'm familiar with the content of the tag wiki. With hindsight, I think it was a mistake to lump it all in a single tag, and current usage (both mine and others') is to use boot for what happens before the kernel is loaded and startup for what happens after the root device is mounted, with some fluctuatation for what happens in between. I agree that most questions will need another tag, such as “startup solaris how do I run a service at boot time?”, but that's the case of most questions in general. –  Gilles Jan 2 '13 at 18:25
Your last example is a good illustration of the problem: "startup How do I run a service at boot time?" I'm not sure trying to retag for the "U&L meaning of these words" is worth the effort. –  Mat Jan 2 '13 at 18:27
@Mat But I'm not proposing to retag: according to my admittedly non-scientific eyeball estimate, most posts already follow this distinction in their tagging. I'm proposing to make this distinction official in the tag wiki, and retag the few outliers. –  Gilles Jan 2 '13 at 18:38
add comment

1 Answer

This proposal seems fine to me.

I don't see a huge problem with putting initrd issues in both categories when applicable.

add comment

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .