There seems to appear question about operating systems/architecture in general (like spin locks or memory handling). Are those on-topic (and therefore in possible clash with operating system development) or off-topic?

share
add comment

2 Answers 2

up vote 4 down vote accepted

That's a good question. I found them both interesting, but I'm interested in programming; they don't really seem on-topic for a site that helps people with *nix. I guess if it was a question about how the Linux kernel specifically does something that makes sense, but general questions about what a spin lock is probably aren't

share
add comment

I understand these questions as having an implicit “on a typical unix system” (just like when someone asks for software do do X, I assume that running on unix is a requirement even if that's not explicitly stated).

I do consider questions about the design of unix systems to be on-topic (they have even more legitimacy than history questions, which I also support).

I'm not a big fan of Sen and Renjith's questions, but my problem with them is not topicality, it's that they tend to ask overly broad questions. I think they would benefit more from reading a book or Wikipedia, and asking more specific questions about point they don't understand here.

share
add comment

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .